Irish watchdog fines Google over tracking
Tuesday, 22 September 2026
Lesson plan for about 60 minutes of class time
Interactive lesson: about 15–20 minutes
Warm-up
- When did you last change a phone privacy setting? Why?
- What benefits do you get from location-based services?
- Which tech firms, if any, do you trust with your data?
Vocabulary
- regulator
- an authority that sets and enforces rules in a sector
- manipulate
- to influence someone in an unfair or hidden way
- infer
- to reach a conclusion from clues rather than explicit statements
- geolocation
- finding a device’s position using digital signals
- surveillance
- close monitoring of people or behaviour, often by organisations
- compliance
- the act of following a law, rule or official order
- enforcement
- actions that ensure rules are obeyed, including penalties
- spokesperson
- a person who officially speaks for an organisation
Reading
It was Ireland’s Data Protection Commission (DPC) that fined Google €403m for how it processed users’ location data, after complaints from seven European consumer groups that the company manipulated people into constant phone tracking. The case began with 2018 research by Norway’s consumer agency suggesting geolocation can expose private facts such as religion, political leanings, hospital visits and sexual orientation.
After a six-year investigation, the DPC said users could have been unaware their location was used to target adverts or to infer their interests and health. The watchdog examined “web and app activity”, “location history” and “location accuracy” between 25 May 2018 and 4 February 2020, and ordered compliance with the EU’s GDPR within six months. BEUC, the European Consumer Organisation, called geolocation one of the most invasive forms of consumer surveillance and warned that late enforcement weakens protection.
A Google spokesperson said the ruling concerns historical policies and that, from 2019, the firm launched tools making location controls simpler. The Irish regulator has also fined Meta €1.2bn, TikTok €530m and Instagram €405m, reflecting its EU-wide role over US tech firms headquartered in Ireland.
Adapted with AI assistance from the original article. Checked by automated tests before publishing; mistakes found later are corrected. Spotted one? Tell us.
Comprehension
- Who imposed the fine and how much was it?
- What sparked the DPC inquiry?
- What did the DPC say users might not have realised?
- Which data features did the DPC examine and what deadline did it set?
- Name one other company previously fined by the Irish regulator.
Grammar focus
Adding emphasis - cleft sentences
Use a cleft (It + be + X + that/who) to emphasise X. The cleft highlights one part of the sentence for focus. (Examples constructed.)
- It was Ireland's Data Protection Commission (DPC) that fined Google €403m.
- It is geolocation that can expose private facts such as religion.
Grammar exercise
Circle the correct option in each sentence.
- It was consumer groups (that / what) raised complaints in Europe.
- It was Google's spokesperson (which / who) mentioned the tools.
- It was a Norwegian study (that / what) started the case.
- It was the GDPR (what / that) the DPC ordered Google to follow.
- It was researchers in Norway (which / who) studied geolocation.
Discussion
- Are large fines enough to change big tech behaviour? Why or why not?
- When does helpful location data become invasive surveillance?
- Should regulators act faster even if cases are complex?
- How much control do users really have over tracking settings?
For teachers
Timing
- warm-up · 8–10 minutes
- vocabulary · 10 minutes
- reading · 12–15 minutes
- comprehension · 12–15 minutes
- grammar · 8–10 minutes
- discussion · 12–15 minutes
Teacher's notes
- Pre-teach regulator, manipulate, infer, surveillance, compliance, geolocation; check learners can explain GDPR and phone location settings in simple terms.
- Run the reading in pairs, then clarify as a class. The topic touches privacy and sensitive inferences (religion, health, sexual orientation), so invite learners to discuss the news without sharing personal data and say they may answer in general rather than personally.
- Differentiation: stronger students summarise BEUC’s critique in two sentences; others list three concrete benefits and three harms of location data, then compare.
Answers
Show answersHide answers
Comprehension
- Ireland’s Data Protection Commission; €403m.
- Research by Norway’s consumer agency on risks from geolocation.
- That location data was used to target adverts or infer interests and health.
- Web and app activity, location history and location accuracy; six months to comply with GDPR.
- Meta, TikTok or Instagram.
Grammar exercise
- It was consumer groups (that / what) raised complaints in Europe. that
- It was Google's spokesperson (which / who) mentioned the tools. who
- It was a Norwegian study (that / what) started the case. that
- It was the GDPR (what / that) the DPC ordered Google to follow. that
- It was researchers in Norway (which / who) studied geolocation. who
The printable PDF has the same notes and answers, laid out for class.
Vocabulary, reading, and exercises with instant feedback
Spotted a mistake in this lesson? Tell us.