Italy fines Meta over Android photo access

Monday, 16 November 2026

Illustrative photo: A long table in a large room with paintings on the walls.

Photo by Nuno Lemos on Unsplash

Illustrative photo: A long table in a large room with paintings on the walls.

Lesson plan for about 60 minutes of class time

Interactive lesson: about 15–20 minutes

Warm-up

  1. How do you protect your privacy on your phone?
  2. When did you last change an app’s permissions? Why?
  3. What information should apps ask for before you use them?

Vocabulary

regulator
an official authority that makes and enforces rules in a sector
consent
permission you give for something to happen
metadata
information about a file, such as time, location or device details
appeal
to ask a higher authority to change a decision or penalty
feature
a specific function or tool inside an app or device
authorisation
official permission to access or do something
disable
to turn off a function so it cannot operate
turnover
a company’s total sales or revenue in a period

Reading

0:00 / --:--

In November 2026, Italy’s data protection regulator fined Meta €805m ($887m). It said the Facebook Android app accessed Italian users’ photos, videos and metadata without specific consent or clear information. The case centres on the gallery suggestions feature, launched in 2023, which suggests photos and videos from a phone gallery as ideas for posts.

According to the regulator, Facebook sought one broad authorisation for the whole app and showed only a generic notice. Users could not see that they were also allowing gallery suggestions. The regulator ordered Meta to seek separate, specific consent for this feature, explain that it accesses the photo gallery, and show how to disable it.

The authority said about 20 million Android users in Italy were affected. It called the infringement ongoing for people who have not updated the app or have already granted consent. Meta plans to appeal, calling the fine disproportionate. The regulator also cited Meta’s lack of cooperation and said the penalty is about 0.4% of the group’s 2025 turnover of $201bn. The penalty was compared with a 2021 Amazon fine later cut on appeal.

Original source

Adapted with AI assistance from the original article. Checked by automated tests before publishing; mistakes found later are corrected. Spotted one? Tell us.

Comprehension

  1. How much did Italy fine Meta?
  2. Which app and platform were involved in the case?
  3. What did the regulator say was wrong with Facebook’s permission request?
  4. What did the regulator order Meta to do?
  5. How many Android users in Italy were affected, according to the authority?

Grammar focus

Wish / if only

Use wish/if only + past simple for a change you want now; wish/if only + had + past participle for a past regret; wish + would + base verb for something you want to happen or stop. (Examples constructed.)

  • Officials wish they had explained the feature clearly.
  • Users wish Meta would show how to disable it.

Practise this grammar: Wish and if only (B2)

More practice on wish and if only: try the grammar bot →

Grammar exercise

Complete each sentence: use the correct wish/if only form of the verb.

  1. Users wish the app (request) ___ separate consent next time.
  2. If only some people (update) ___ the app before 2024.
  3. Regulators wish companies (cooperate) ___ more in future checks.
  4. Users wish fines (be) ___ higher for privacy breaches.
  5. I wish I (not/allow) ___ gallery access in the first place.

Discussion

  1. Should one broad permission ever cover multiple app features? Why?
  2. What app permissions do you usually refuse, and why?
  3. Is a 0.4% revenue penalty enough to change big tech behaviour?
  4. How clearly should apps explain metadata collection to users?

For teachers

Timing

  • 8–10 minutes warm-up, 10 minutes vocabulary, 12–15 minutes reading, 10 minutes comprehension, 10 minutes discussion. Combine grammar timing with reading if needed.

Teacher's notes

  • Pre-teach or board: regulator, consent, metadata, authorisation. Highlight the difference between enabling a feature and granting consent.
  • Reading and discussion: do a first skim for key figures (fine, users affected). Then scan for reasons and remedies. Privacy can feel personal, so let students answer in general terms about apps rather than their own devices if they prefer.
  • Differentiation: stronger students summarise the regulator’s orders in one sentence; others underline app actions vs user actions before paraphrasing.

Answers

Show answers

Comprehension

  1. €805m ($887m).
  2. The Facebook app on Android devices.
  3. It used one broad authorisation and a generic notice, without specific consent.
  4. Seek separate, specific consent, explain access to the gallery, and show how to disable it.
  5. About 20 million users.

Grammar exercise

  1. Users wish the app (request) ___ separate consent next time. would request
  2. If only some people (update) ___ the app before 2024. had updated
  3. Regulators wish companies (cooperate) ___ more in future checks. would cooperate
  4. Users wish fines (be) ___ higher for privacy breaches. were be / would be
  5. I wish I (not/allow) ___ gallery access in the first place. hadn't allowed / had not allowed

The printable PDF has the same notes and answers, laid out for class.

Start Interactive Lesson

Vocabulary, reading, and exercises with instant feedback

Spotted a mistake in this lesson? Tell us.