High-mileage EVs outperform petrol in MOTs
Tuesday, 22 September 2026
Lesson plan for about 60 minutes of class time
Interactive lesson: about 15–20 minutes
Warm-up
- What do you check first when buying a used car?
- Do you trust high-mileage cars? Why or why not?
- What costs worry you most with a used car?
Vocabulary
- reliable
- able to be trusted to work well over time
- mileage
- the number of miles a vehicle has driven
- fail
- to not pass a test or standard
- consultancy
- a company that gives expert advice for a fee
- leasing
- using something for a set time by paying regular fees
- tyre
- the rubber cover around a wheel
- corrosion
- slow damage caused by rust or a chemical reaction
- roadworthiness
- being safe and legal to drive on public roads
Reading
High-mileage electric cars appear more reliable than petrol ones, a UK study says. New AutoMotive, a consultancy, analysed 47.4m MOT tests for the BVRLA. Between 90,000 and 120,000 miles, 16.5% of EVs failed, compared with 22.1% of petrol cars. Beyond 120,000 miles, 16% of EVs failed versus 23.5% of petrol. At lower mileage, the gap was small.
Many used EVs come from company and leasing fleets, so they often have high mileage. BVRLA chief Toby Poston said mileage alone should not put buyers off. Focusing only on mileage could make buyers pass over a good EV.
The study also found weak spots for EVs, especially tyres. EVs recorded nearly twice as many tyre defects. Some older, low-mileage EVs had more friction-brake issues, likely from corrosion. MOTs check roadworthiness — brakes, tyres, suspension, steering and lights — but not battery health. Buyers should review a car's history, condition, tyres and battery health.
Adapted with AI assistance from the original article. Checked by automated tests before publishing; mistakes found later are corrected. Spotted one? Tell us.
Comprehension
- Who carried out the study and for which organisation?
- What were the EV and petrol failure rates at 90,000–120,000 miles?
- What happened to failure rates beyond 120,000 miles?
- In which areas did EVs perform worse than petrol cars?
- What do MOT tests check, and what do they not measure?
Grammar focus
Second conditional
Use If + past simple ... would + base verb to talk about unreal or unlikely present/future situations. The if-clause uses a past form and the result clause uses would + verb. (Examples constructed.)
- If buyers judged only mileage, they would miss good EVs.
- If a leasing firm offered more checks, customers would feel safer.
Practise this grammar: The second conditional (B1) · Unreal conditionals (B2)
More practice on the second conditional: try the grammar bot →
Grammar exercise
Complete the sentences with the correct form of the verb in brackets.
- If drivers (prefer) ___ low running costs, they would choose EVs.
- If EV tyres (last) ___ longer, owners would spend less.
- If companies (sell) ___ more used EVs, prices would fall.
- If petrol cars (have) ___ fewer faults, they would pass more MOTs.
- If buyers (want) ___ longer warranties, dealers would include them.
Discussion
- Would you consider a high-mileage EV? Why or why not?
- What used-car checks are most important to you?
- Should sellers show battery health on used EVs?
- How could your city support reliable used EVs?
For teachers
Timing
- warm-up · 8 minutes
- vocabulary · 10 minutes
- reading · 12 minutes
- comprehension · 10 minutes
- grammar · 8–10 minutes
- discussion · 10–12 minutes
Teacher's notes
- Pre-teach or check: MOT (UK vehicle test), mileage, consultancy, leasing, tyre, corrosion, roadworthiness.
- Run the reading in two passes: gist first, then figures and names. Pair-check answers before brief whole-class feedback to lower number stress around percentages.
- Differentiation: stronger students extract two extra data points from the text (names, percentages, or test items) to summarise; others underline where each answer was found.
Answers
Show answersHide answers
Comprehension
- New AutoMotive did it for the BVRLA.
- EVs failed at 16.5% and petrol cars at 22.1%.
- 16% of EVs failed versus 23.5% of petrol cars.
- Tyres, and some friction-brake issues on older low-mileage EVs.
- They check brakes, tyres, suspension, steering and lights, but not battery health.
Grammar exercise
- If drivers (prefer) ___ low running costs, they would choose EVs. preferred
- If EV tyres (last) ___ longer, owners would spend less. lasted
- If companies (sell) ___ more used EVs, prices would fall. sold
- If petrol cars (have) ___ fewer faults, they would pass more MOTs. had
- If buyers (want) ___ longer warranties, dealers would include them. wanted
The printable PDF has the same notes and answers, laid out for class.
Vocabulary, reading, and exercises with instant feedback
Spotted a mistake in this lesson? Tell us.