BusinessB1Both/either/neither

Australian states consider $50bn tobacco case

Thursday, 12 November 2026

Illustrative photo: Sydney opera house near body of water during daytime.

Photo by Caleb on Unsplash

Illustrative photo: Sydney opera house near body of water during daytime.

Lesson plan for about 60 minutes of class time

Interactive lesson: about 15–20 minutes

Warm-up

  1. How common is smoking where you live?
  2. Who should pay for smoking-related health care? Why?
  3. What anti-smoking rules do you see in public places?

Vocabulary

proposal
an official plan or idea that someone suggests
sue
to take a person or company to court to get money or justice
compensation
money paid to cover damage, loss or costs
liable
legally responsible for something harmful
misleading
making someone believe something that is not true
evidence
facts that show something is true
screening
tests to find a disease early, before symptoms appear
taskforce
a special team formed to do a specific job

Reading

0:00 / --:--

Australian state governments are considering a proposal to sue tobacco companies for up to $50bn in compensation for hospital and healthcare costs.

South Australia is formally seeking advice, and other states are reviewing the idea. The case would target British American Tobacco, Philip Morris and Imperial Brands, and could argue the firms are liable under consumer law for misleading conduct. The six states would pool resources in a legal taskforce.

The plan seeks to recover costs since 2000, after internal documents from that year provided evidence the industry knew about serious health risks. Any funds could support cancer screening and prevention programmes. The proposal says these costs have often been paid either by smokers or by taxpayers. A BAT spokesperson said it does not comment on potential legal claims.

Original source

Adapted with AI assistance from the original article. Checked by automated tests before publishing; mistakes found later are corrected. Spotted one? Tell us.

Comprehension

  1. Which state is formally seeking advice on the plan?
  2. How much money could the states seek, according to the plan?
  3. Which companies would the case target?
  4. Since what year does the plan aim to recover healthcare costs?
  5. What could any funds from the case support?

Grammar focus

Both/either/neither

Both = two together (plural noun/verb). Either = one of two (singular). Neither = not one of two (singular). You can use either/neither of + plural noun (often a singular verb). (Examples constructed.)

  • Two cafés near me are smoke-free, and both cafés are busy.
  • A state can sue now or wait; either choice has risks.

More practice on both, either and neither: try the grammar bot →

Grammar exercise

Circle the correct option in each sentence.

  1. The case targets (either / both) BAT and Philip Morris.
  2. Both my parents smoked, but (either / neither) smokes now.
  3. Funds may support (both / either) screening and prevention.
  4. We have two hospitals; (both / either) hospital can treat you.
  5. I had two screenings; (neither of / both of) them was painful.

Discussion

  1. Should governments sue companies for long-term health costs? Why or why not?
  2. If the states win money, what should be funded first?
  3. Is it fair for taxpayers to cover smoking-related health costs?
  4. Who gives more trustworthy health information: companies or governments?

For teachers

Timing

  • warm-up · 8–10 minutes
  • vocabulary · 10 minutes
  • reading and comprehension · 12–15 minutes
  • grammar · 8–10 minutes
  • discussion · 10 minutes

Teacher's notes

  • Pre-teach terms and names: tobacco company, compensation, consumer law, screening, taskforce; check students understand sue, liable and misleading.
  • Do a first skim for the key figure ($50bn), then a second read for actors (states, companies) and timeline (since 2000) before pairs answer questions. The topic involves serious illness and addiction, so start the discussion in pairs and say students may speak about the news rather than personal stories.
  • Differentiation: stronger students map the legal steps (proposal → review → taskforce → court), while others highlight lines showing who does what and how funds might be used.

Answers

Show answers

Comprehension

  1. South Australia.
  2. Up to $50bn in compensation.
  3. British American Tobacco, Philip Morris and Imperial Brands.
  4. Since 2000.
  5. Cancer screening and prevention programmes.

Grammar exercise

  1. The case targets (either / both) BAT and Philip Morris. both
  2. Both my parents smoked, but (either / neither) smokes now. neither
  3. Funds may support (both / either) screening and prevention. both
  4. We have two hospitals; (both / either) hospital can treat you. either
  5. I had two screenings; (neither of / both of) them was painful. neither of

The printable PDF has the same notes and answers, laid out for class.

Start Interactive Lesson

Vocabulary, reading, and exercises with instant feedback

Spotted a mistake in this lesson? Tell us.